As a finance professional, I often see 401(k) plans treated as set-and-forget investments. Many plan sponsors and participants assume that simply offering or contributing to a 401(k) is enough. But without benchmarking, you may miss critical inefficiencies that erode long-term returns. In this article, I will explain why benchmarking a 401(k) is essential, how it improves performance, and what metrics matter most.
Table of Contents
Why Benchmarking a 401(k) Matters
Benchmarking compares your 401(k) plan’s performance, fees, and structure against industry standards or peer plans. Without this comparison, you operate in the dark. A well-benchmarked plan ensures participants get competitive returns while avoiding excessive fees.
Consider this: if your plan’s large-cap equity fund underperforms the S&P 500 by 2% annually over 30 years, a \$100,000 investment could grow to \$432,194 instead of \$761,225 (assuming a 7% vs. 9% return). That’s a \$328,000 difference due to poor fund selection.
Key Metrics to Benchmark
- Investment Performance – Compare funds against relevant indices (e.g., S&P 500 for US equities).
- Fee Structures – Assess administrative, advisory, and expense ratio costs.
- Participation Rates – Measure employee engagement against industry averages.
- Employer Match Effectiveness – Evaluate if your match structure incentivizes savings.
How Benchmarking Improves 401(k) Performance
1. Identifying Underperforming Funds
Not all funds deliver. Some lag behind their benchmarks due to high fees or poor management. By comparing returns, you can replace weak performers.
Example Calculation:
If a fund charges a 1.2% expense ratio but returns 6% vs. an index fund with a 0.05% fee returning 8%, the net difference is:
Net\ Return = Gross\ Return - Expense\ Ratio
Fund\ A = 6\% - 1.2\% = 4.8\%
Fund\ B = 8\% - 0.05\% = 7.95\%
Over 20 years, \$10,000 grows to:
Fund\ A = 10,000 \times (1 + 0.048)^{20} = \$25,586
Fund\ B = 10,000 \times (1 + 0.0795)^{20} = \$46,610
The lower-cost index fund nearly doubles the outcome.
2. Reducing Excessive Fees
Fees silently erode returns. The Department of Labor (DOL) requires fee transparency, yet many plans still overpay. Benchmarking reveals if you’re above market averages.
Average 401(k) Fees (Source: BrightScope)
| Fee Type | Small Plans (<100 participants) | Large Plans (>1000 participants) |
|---|---|---|
| Admin Fees | 1.20% | 0.50% |
| Investment Fees | 0.80% | 0.30% |
| Total | 2.00% | 0.80% |
If your plan’s total fees exceed these averages, benchmarking helps negotiate better terms.
3. Enhancing Participation and Contributions
Low participation hurts retirement readiness. Benchmarking identifies gaps—such as poor employee education or weak match incentives—and suggests fixes.
Participation Rate Benchmarks (Vanguard 2023 Data)
| Employee Demographics | Average Participation Rate |
|---|---|
| Auto-enrollment plans | 92% |
| Opt-in plans | 62% |
| Plans with 6%+ match | 85% |
If your participation lags, auto-enrollment or a better match structure may help.
The Fiduciary Advantage of Benchmarking
As a plan sponsor, ERISA holds you to a fiduciary standard. Benchmarking provides documented proof of due diligence. If challenged, you can demonstrate:
- Regular fund performance reviews
- Competitive fee analysis
- Efforts to improve participant outcomes
Courts often side with sponsors who benchmark. In Tussey v. ABB, a lack of fee benchmarking led to a \$36 million judgment against the plan sponsor.
Practical Steps to Benchmark Your 401(k)
- Compare Funds to Indices – Use Morningstar or Lipper data.
- Audit Fees – Check Form 5500 filings for competitor benchmarks.
- Survey Employees – Assess satisfaction and financial literacy gaps.
- Consult an Advisor – Independent advisors provide unbiased comparisons.
Conclusion
Benchmarking a 401(k) isn’t optional—it’s a fiduciary necessity. By measuring performance, fees, and participation against industry standards, you safeguard participant retirements and mitigate legal risks. The math is clear: small improvements in fees and returns compound into life-changing differences. If you haven’t benchmarked your plan recently, now is the time.
